[1706] Instance naming shouldn't be VRC+ locked
Undertrash
I don't think the ability to name instances should be locked behind VRC+.
Named public instances are far more attractive to players than unnamed ones, which means non-subscribers will be discouraged from making their own instances. This is already somewhat proven by the popularity of Group Public instances, not because the groups are moderating them (they rarely are), but simply because players like the names associated with these instances.
Additionally, by locking naming behind VRC+, non-subscribers are encouraged to use awkward workarounds like using the API or editing website links. This creates an unnecessary barrier for regular players and makes the feature feel incomplete.
Since instance naming will be widespread and an objective improvement over the old system, it feels wrong to treat it as a premium perk rather than a core upgrade available to everyone.
Log In
Slone Fallion
As a VRC+ supporter, I agree with this. We've had named LAN and Internet lobbies since the 90's. A description of the instance that someone is joining, which benefits everyone involved, being locked behind a paywall seems to be extremely counter-intuitive. Especially so if this functionality is expanded to let groups use it for public instances.
Also, the bit about not removing the free existing naming functionality from API isn't true, unless the direction has changed from the May 2, 2024 developer update. In that update, we have been asked to stop using that API and that the instance auto-create function that makes it possible will be killed. https://ask.vrchat.com/t/developer-update-2-may-2024/24284
To copy my comment from that post:
Not very happy about the Instance ID no longer being customizable. The list below means absolutely nothing to me when looking at a world instance to join. The name of the group or topic as the instance ID is much more descriptive.
91440 - Group Public
44512 - Group Public
04455 - Group Public
97521 - Group Public
12334 - Group Public
07889 - Group Public