Untrusted URLs (Video Player Allowed Domains) is limited to 10, which is too few.
available in future release
narazaka
I am not in favor of a uniform Untrusted URL restriction in Public instances, but I tried to add Video Player Allowed Domains anyway.
However, I was only able to add up to 10. This is too few!
For example, nicovrc.net, a service for proxy viewing of videos from video sites that cannot be played normally, supports Nico Nico Douga, bilibili Douga, TikTok, and many other platforms, with different domains redirected to each platform. You must allow at least 6 URLs to function properly.
And just to play a video on X (Twitter), you have to allow x.com and video.twimg.com.
Ten is a number that fills up quickly and is not practical.
I think it is necessary to either make the number of Video Player Allowed Domains registrations virtually unlimited (e.g., 100) or to make it possible to have a deny list instead of an allow list.
私はPublicインスタンスでの一律なUntrusted URL制限にあまり賛成しない立場ですが、とりあえずVideo Player Allowed Domainsを追加しようとしました。
しかし10個までしか追加することが出来ませんでした。これは少なすぎます!
例えば標準では再生できない動画サイトの動画をプロキシ視聴するためのサービスであるnicovrc.netはニコニコ動画やbilibili動画、TikTok、その他多くのプラットフォームに対応していますが、プラットフォームごとにリダイレクトされるドメインが異なります。正しく機能するために少なくとも6つ以上のURLを許可しなければなりません。
またX(Twitter)の動画を再生するだけでも、x.comとvideo.twimg.comの2つを許可しなければなりません。
10個という数はすぐに埋まってしまい、実用的ではありません。
Video Player Allowed Domainsの登録数を実質的に無制限(100個など)にするか、許可リストではなく拒否リストに出来るようにするかが必要だと思います。
Log In
This post was marked as
available in future release
StormRel
tracked
narazaka
StormRel or more built-in whitelists, that contains niconico live servers and the proxy services, might be the another solution.
narazaka
StormRel available in future release? Please add the bilibili urls as well (if the solution is to add built-in urls).
D
Docteh
I'm pretty sure this feature is aimed at supporting worlds that host thier own content, not really just using other services.
narazaka
Docteh No to aims that do not face real use case.
narazaka
Wildcards are also a partial solution. https://feedback.vrchat.com/open-beta/p/1546-add-support-for-wildcard-domains-in-domain-allowlist
narazaka
No, on the contrary, it is virtually impossible to watch Nico Nico Live broadcasts, etc. with the current restriction system because the destination of the second redirect is undefined.
There are sites that are virtually as safe as YouTube without at least a wildcard, yet are completely unavailable for viewing.